JDBC vs ODBC: Comparing Data Access Technologies

Enterprises are awash with data. But unfortunately, enterprises store data in all kinds of places: the cloud, on-premises, in MS SQL Server, MySQL, or MongoDB databases. There are countless data sources. Data access technologies, such as JDBC, ODBC or OData, exist to solve this problem.

In our JDBC vs ODBC guide, we explore what these data access technologies are and how they compare.

This guide is written for developers who need to understand how to create data-centric applications that consume data stored in either a single or multiple sources. It also introduces OData, a more modern technology that can replace JDBC or ODBC in most use cases.

JDBC vs ODBC: Understanding Universal Data Access Technologies

JDBC and ODBC were invented to address the need for standardized, efficient ways to connect applications to relational databases. Both are essential in solving the problem of database connectivity across diverse systems and platforms.

What is ODBC?

Open Database Connectivity (ODBC) is a widely supported standard interface for connecting to databases. Developed in the early 1990s by Microsoft, ODBC was designed to provide a database management system (DBMS)-independent method for processing relational database data.

ODBC is widely used to enable communication between database management systems and applications typically written in C or C++. It serves as a common interface between web applications and database servers, enabling SQL statements to be issued in a standardized manner.

ODBC functions as an application programming interface (API) that allows client-side programs to communicate with DBMSs, provided the necessary software is installed on both the client and server platforms.

Created to access relational databases and table-like data sources, ODBC offers an open, vendor-neutral way to access data, simplifying the process of migrating from one database system to another.

Its widespread adoption, particularly by Microsoft, has made ODBC a popular choice among software developers.

ODBC and Its Modern Usage

Open Database Connectivity (ODBC) is an API that allows applications to interact with different database management systems (DBMSs) using a standardized set of commands, regardless of the database’s underlying architecture.

In modern usage, ODBC remains a widely used standard for database access, particularly in environments where cross-platform compatibility and database portability are important.

It enables applications to connect to a variety of database types, including traditional relational databases like SQL Server, MySQL, and PostgreSQL, as well as non-relational data sources that have table-like structures.

ODBC’s relevance today is sustained by its ability to act as a bridge between applications and databases in diverse environments, such as web applications, desktop software, and even cloud-based solutions.

Although newer technologies like OLE DB, ADO.NET, and ORM frameworks (e.g., Entity Framework) have emerged, ODBC is still frequently used in legacy systems, enterprise environments, and situations where stability, reliability, and vendor-neutrality are prioritized.

Its ongoing support by major database vendors and compatibility with a wide range of operating systems ensure that ODBC continues to be a critical tool for universal database access.

What is JDBC?

JDBC (Java Database Connectivity) is Oracle’s version of ODBC, designed specifically for accessing relational database management systems (DBMS) from Java applications. It is the most widely used method for connecting Java programs to relational databases.

JDBC defines a database access API that supports basic SQL operations and enables interaction with a broad range of relational DBMSs. The JDBC API is composed of two primary interfaces: one for application developers and a lower-level driver API for those creating drivers. To facilitate database access through JDBC, Oracle has identified four types of drivers.

The first driver type translates JDBC calls directly into the network protocol used by the DBMS, allowing direct communication between the client and the DBMS server.

The second type converts JDBC calls into a protocol used by middleware, which then translates them into the DBMS protocol.

The third driver type converts JDBC calls into the native API calls of the DBMS, but requires the driver software to be installed on client machines.

The fourth type uses a JDBC-ODBC Bridge, which allows JDBC to interface with ODBC drivers, enabling Java applications to access ODBC data sources. This method also necessitates loading the software driver on each client machine.

Additionally, there is a JDBC-based approach that uses embedded SQL within Java, known as JSQL. This extension of the ISO/ANSI standard for embedded SQL allows for the inclusion of SQL within Java code.

A JSQL translator converts the embedded SQL into standard Java code that interacts with the database through a call-level interface.

Overall, JDBC is a low-level middleware tool that provides a database access interface for Java applications.

JDBC and Its Modern Usage

JDBC remains a cornerstone technology for Java developers working with databases.

It is widely used in enterprise environments, especially in applications running on Java EE (Enterprise Edition) servers.

JDBC drivers, which come in different types, allow Java applications to communicate with various databases, including Oracle, MySQL, PostgreSQL, and SQL Server. The flexibility of JDBC, combined with Java’s platform independence, makes it a popular choice for developing cross-platform database applications.

In modern usage, JDBC is still prevalent. However, it often serves as the underlying layer for higher-level frameworks like Hibernate, Spring Data, and JPA (Java Persistence API).

These frameworks simplify database interaction by abstracting away much of the low-level JDBC code, allowing developers to work with objects rather than SQL directly.

Despite the rise of these frameworks, JDBC remains essential for situations where fine-grained control over database operations is required or when working with legacy systems that rely on direct database access.

JDBC’s continued relevance is also supported by the ongoing development of new drivers and updates to existing ones, ensuring compatibility with the latest database versions and features. Whether used directly or through an abstraction layer, JDBC is a critical component of Java-based database applications.

JDBC vs ODBC: Summary

JDBC (Java Database Connectivity) and ODBC (Open Database Connectivity) are both APIs designed to facilitate the interaction between applications and databases, but they serve different ecosystems and have distinct use cases.

ODBC is a universal, language-agnostic interface developed in the early 1990s that allows applications to access a variety of relational databases using SQL. Its primary strength lies in its vendor-neutral approach, enabling seamless migration between different database systems. ODBC has been widely adopted across various platforms, particularly in environments where cross-platform compatibility and database independence are critical.

On the other hand, JDBC is specifically tailored for the Java programming environment. Introduced by Sun Microsystems (now Oracle), JDBC provides a standardized way for Java applications to connect to relational databases, execute SQL queries, and manage transactions.

While JDBC is focused on the Java ecosystem, offering a more direct and optimized approach for Java-based applications, ODBC’s broader scope makes it applicable in a wider range of programming languages and platforms. Despite their differences, both JDBC and ODBC continue to play vital roles in database connectivity, with JDBC being the go-to choice for Java developers and ODBC offering a more universal solution.

OData: A Modern Data Access Alternative

OData (Open Data Protocol) is a modern, web-based data access protocol developed by Microsoft, offering an alternative to traditional database connectivity methods like JDBC and ODBC.

OData is similar to Open Database Connectivity (ODBC) and Java Database Connectivity (JDBC). As a more modern technology, OData can replace ODBC and JDBC for most uses.

Unlike these older APIs, which are primarily designed for accessing relational databases through SQL, OData provides a more flexible and platform-independent approach to accessing data over the web using standard HTTP protocols.

OData leverages RESTful principles, allowing for easy integration with a wide range of clients, including web, mobile, and cloud-based applications. It enables the querying, filtering, and manipulation of data in a standardized format such as JSON or XML, making it ideal for scenarios where data needs to be accessed and manipulated across different devices and platforms.

One of the key advantages of OData is its ability to expose data from various sources, not limited to relational databases, through a unified service interface.

This makes it particularly useful in environments where data integration and interoperability are essential. With OData, developers can build scalable, data-centric applications that can interact with different data sources, such as databases, file systems, and even external APIs, without needing to worry about the underlying database technology.

As a result, OData has gained significant traction in enterprise environments and cloud services, where it simplifies the process of building data-driven applications that need to communicate across disparate systems.

Further Reading

Read more about OData and how it compares to GraphQL here.

Alternatively, sign up for Five and learn how to build modern web apps that use OData as a data provider.

Connect to OData, Build a Web App
Rapidly build and deploy custom software